My great friend and fellow marketing traveler, Owen Ashby, recently had a crisis of confidence brought about by a fairly brutal discussion that appeared to relegate marketing to the minor supporting roles of lead generation and messaging. In order to, as he put it, “ensure he hadn’t lost his marbles” he posed a question on a LinkedIn sales and marketing discussion group about the role of marketing in product development.
For his sanity, there were a lot of people who took a much broader and more strategic view of marketing. But the thing that intrigued me was how quickly the discussion turned to who leads the offer/proposition/product…sales, product management or marketing? In particular, sales can be pretty virulent in their relegation of marketing to a subservient role.
As a marketer, I could be expected to promote the view that marketing has a much wider, strategic role than it is often given credit for. In the mid 80s I was working in sales for Burroughs which was a very sales and product led company. There was a great story doing the rounds about the Burroughs then EMEA head, Graham Murphy, whose reputation for bawling out people he thought were bullshitting him, or not performing was legendary. The story itself may be apocryphal, but it is quite fun and highlights that everything isn’t quite as it seems.
At a quarterly sales review meeting with all the EMEA country managers the Italian country manager was trying to justify to Graham Murphy why he wasn’t on target. “But Graham, I was planning for tomorrow.” To which his response was “I don’t pay you to think about tomorrow, I pay you to get results today.” Having got the hapless country manager to accept he was paid to get results today, Graham Murphy started going around the table asking all the other country managers what they were paid for. Given his fearsome reputation they all dutifully chimed in that they were paid to get results today.
Finally, he got around to the person sitting directly on his right and asked the question again. Like a rabbit caught in the headlights the man came back with the same answer as all the rest. “NO!!” exploded Graham Murphy “you are my strategic marketing manager. I pay YOU to plan for tomorrow.”
Even someone as sales focused as Graham Murphy, working for a notoriously sales and product led company, could not ignore the need for some part of the business to think more broadly, about what customers and markets need and how the company uses the full marketing mix to deliver a competitive, differentiated offer.
I concede that marketing may be partly responsible for the subservient, reactive position it finds itself in. It may also be that the term, Marketing, is now so badly misunderstood and poorly valued, that we will need to coin a different term to cover the development and deployment of market offers using the whole marketing mix. However, while sales are critical in the customer feedback loop process, sales drivers and behaviours preclude sales from owning and driving offer development.
How marketing needs to step up to deliver an agile, continuous offer development environment, is something I will return to…if sales haven’t driven me into hiding first!